Google Ads help pay the expense of maintaining this site
Click Here for the Neighborhood Transformation Website
Fair Use Disclaimer
Neighborhood Transformation is a nonprofit,
noncommercial website that, at times, may contain copyrighted material
that have not always been specifically authorized by the copyright
owner. It makes such material available in its efforts to advance the
understanding of poverty and low income distressed neighborhoods in
hopes of helping to find solutions for those problems. It believes that
this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as
provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. Persons wishing to
use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of their own that
go beyond 'fair use' must first obtain permission from the copyright
Miami Herald - November 12, 2001
Melrose Park residents place hopes for improvements in Ft. Lauderdale.
Unicorporated Areas of Broward are Predominanlty Low Income Black Neighborhooods
that pay Disproportionately Higher Taxes
By Brad Bennett email@example.com
With roads laid out in a circular maze to discourage strangers, with a pool and
tennis club, tree-lined streets, and one-story homes, Melrose Park was once considered
a pricey new subdivision on Broward County's western fringe.
That was 40 years ago.
Today, the western land rush to the Everglades has siphoned off the prestige of
this neighborhood of 7,100 residents bordered by Broward Boulevard, Davie Boulevard,
U.S. 441 and Southwest 31st Avenue.
Voters in this one-square-mile, unincorporated area are fighting to regain some
respect. They voted overwhelmingly on Tuesday in favor of joining the city of Fort
Lauderdale to reduce taxes and improve government services, such as police and fire.
Of the 554 voters who cast ballots, 90.2 percent voted in favor of being annexed
on Sept. 15, 2002.
``For the last year, we've seen the increase in our taxes,'' said Godfrey Johnson,
vice president of the Melrose Park Homeowners Association, citing the neighborhood's
fear of even higher taxes if the area remains in an unincorporated part of the county.
``We feel that this is the best time to take an opportunity.''
Although cities have taken in most of Broward County over the past few decades,
Melrose Park is among three dozen neighborhoods that cities have left out.
Like most of the unwanted communities, Melrose Park's residents are predominantly
black and mostly with low to moderate incomes.
Although unincorporated areas include some of Broward's most disadvantaged residents,
those residents pay disproportionately higher taxes due to rising fees for fire-rescue
service and garbage pickup.
An original annexation proposal submitted to the Florida Legislature would have
allowed Melrose Park residents to be able to pick Fort Lauderdale to the east or
Plantation to the west.
But Plantation lobbied hard against the bill, forcing lawmakers to remove the city
from consideration in order to ensure passage.
Plantation officials said they opposed annexing Melrose out of concern about the
Some residents and lawmakers believe otherwise, arguing that Plantation officials
seemed more receptive to taking in Broadview Park, an area west of U.S. 441 and
south of Davie Boulevard and Peters Road.
Although Broadview Park has a larger white population, it has more lower-income
residents than the majority-black and slightly richer Melrose Park.
But unlike Melrose Park, some Plantation officials said, Broadview Park is a better
geographic fit. RACE A ROLE?
``Unfortunately, Lady Justice is not wearing a blindfold, and it was pretty clear
that race was an issue,'' said state Sen. Mandy Dawson, D-Fort Lauderdale, who championed
the cause of annexing Melrose Park.
Plantation officials maintain that a drain on the tax base, not race, was a factor
in Plantation's efforts to resist annexing Melrose Park.
``Fort Lauderdale's got a broader tax base to lay that cost over than we do,'' Plantation
City Council President Ralph Merritt said, adding that Fort Lauderdale has a paid
fire department that can absorb the paid county firefighters who now serve the area
-- versus Plantation's volunteer fire department.
During the legislative session, Dawson seized on another annexation bill, one involving
another unincorporated but relatively affluent and predominantly white area named
Dawson -- the Broward delegation chairwoman -- held up the Riverland bill in the
Senate until the Melrose Park bill was passed by the House of Representatives.
That sent lawmakers representing Dania Beach and Fort Lauderdale, both of which
covet the high tax revenue that Riverland is expected to bring, working overtime
to salvage the Melrose Park deal, resulting in Tuesday's annexation vote.
Fort Lauderdale City Manager Floyd Johnson is preparing a report on the financial
aspects of annexing Melrose Park and other unincorporated areas. He hopes to have
the report ready by the Nov. 20 city commission meeting.
``What we think is that with Melrose Park and Riverland, we could probably come
close to breaking even in a few years,'' Fort Lauderdale Mayor Jim Naugle said.
A preliminary analysis done earlier this year showed that Melrose Park would create
a loss to Fort Lauderdale of $58,723 in the first year.
But the area would generate positive revenue of $365,775 in the second year, rising
to nearly $2 million by the fifth year.
But Naugle said those figures do not include the cost of additional staff time from
the city manager, city attorney, Building Department, administrative services or
other general government expenses.
Johnson's report is expected to factor in those costs.
While the city tallies up the numbers, Melrose Park residents hope the city not
only will maintain the level of county services but also will provide some improvements.